Universal Life vs guaranteed UL what works best depends on age

Universal Life, UL, has many different life insurance product designations. One of the most basic distinctions is whether it is a UL or a Guaranteed UL.

Guaranteed Universal Life  (Guaranteed UL)
With guaranteed UL there is a lapse protection guarantee: as long as you pay your premium on time, coverage is guaranteed.  Lifetime guaranteed UL is guaranteed to age 121.  Great coverage: inexpensive, straightforward, easy to understand.  Put premium payments on bank draft and forget about it.  Is there a catch?  No.  Well, perhaps in a few ways: guaranteed UL’s lack flexibility on the adjusting the premium amount, the lapse protection is lost if the premium is not paid on time, and guaranteed UL’s do not build much cash value.

Universal Life (UL)
UL’s are called flexible adjustable life insurance for a reason. Premiums are flexible.  There is a target premium.  The real target is to make the life insurance coverage last for the rest of the policy holder’s life. Premium can be raised, lowered or kept the same to meet that target.  It’s sort of like gas in the car.  The idea is to have enough gas (cash value) to reach one’s destination, i.e.  go beyond the person’s lifespan. At the policy’s beginning, target premium is typically set to age 100.  The car’s (i.e. carrier) performance helps determine how much gas (premium) is needed.  With a UL the holder is obliged to take a much more active role in management of the policy.

Does my age affect which type I choose?
Yes, generally select a UL in 40’s and 50’s, and a guaranteed UL in 60’s, 70’s and 80’s

Universal Life: 40’s and 50’s
When younger, in your 40’s or 50’s, you want the flexibility of regular universal life to lower or raise premium payments depending on your financial situation, to build higher cash value and to possibly replace your coverage for a better product later on.

For example:

Mrs. Wright, age 46, takes out a $250,000 universal life policy with the target premium of $150 a month.   Five years later, her child needs braces and her monthly budget is tight.   Since there is $3,000 cash value in her policy, Mrs. Wright, after reviewing an in force illustration, lowers her premium to $100 a month.   One year later after getting back on better financial footing, Mrs. Wright increases her premium to $200 a month until the policy back on track to the original target of age 100.  Later she is able to lower the premium back down to $150 a month.

Guaranteed UL: 60’s, 70’s and 80’s

When older, lock in a benefit amount for a set premium for life.

For example:

Mr. Ward, age 68, would like to leave $500,000 to his son.  He chooses a guaranteed universal life product because the premiums are fixed and the policy is guaranteed to age 121.   He has a secure retirement income and can well afford a fixed premium payment.  He puts those payments on bank draft and can rest assured that this portion of his estate plan is secure.

Life insurance to pay off a reverse mortgage

First let’s assume a homeowner does adequate research including taking a long hard look at the disadvantages and alternatives decides a reverse mortgage appropriate for their situation. Granted, many homeowners will need every penny of this money, but some may desire to tap into home equity for discretionary funds and have broader goals.  For example, those who want an heir to keep the house, life insurance is a means to pay off the reverse mortgage’s loan balance.

For those in average or better than average health, life insurance is readily available in one’s 60’s, 70’s, and even 80’s.   For joint policies only one of a couple needs to be healthy to qualify; the other can be uninsurable.

There are two forms of life insurance: term and permanent.   Term level premium ends in 10, 15 or 20 years, so in generally term is not suitable to cover a reverse mortgage’s lifetime commitment.  For permanent there is whole life and universal life, which comes in many forms.  The best product to cover a reverse mortgages is guaranteed universal life.   It’s fixed rate and coverage for life, usually to age 121.   All the policyholder has to do to is pay the premiums on time.   Couples can get joint coverage, also known as second to die coverage, with a joint survivor guaranteed UL.  How much does a guaranteed UL cost?   There are sample rates by age on the right hand side for individuals.   Please contact me for your own personalized quote.  Here’s an example.

Mr. and Mrs. Jones, both 73 and in good health, needs funds for retirement but want to leave their lakeside home to their daughter, so they decide upon a reverse mortgage.  They qualify for a lump sum payment of $250,000.  They take out a $350,000 joint survivor life insurance policy so their daughter may pay back interest and principal on the loan, and also as a contingency against declining home value.  A $350,000 joint survivor guaranteed UL with Prudential is $650.00 a month, at the preferred non tobacco rate.

If this couple were in average health, this Prudential joint coverage is $887.00 a month at the standard rate.  To show you how joint policies compare to individual, using this example a $350,000 individual policy for a woman is $768.38 a month with Lincoln National and $1,009.23 a month for a 73 year old man with Banner Life.

Keep in mind the heirs can be the owners and beneficiaries of life insurance policy and pay a portion or all of the premiums.

Ruling to contest Stranger-Originated Life Insurance: dead pools precedent

Bloomberg reports on a Delaware court ruling which opens an avenue to curb stranger-originated life insurance. Life companies now can contest the owner’s insurable interest even after the standard two year contestability period.

Normally, life insurance implies an insurable interest.   A wife who depends on her husband’s income has an insurable interest,  if he dies.   Two business partners who depend upon each other to run a company have an insurable interest.  Normally, insurable interest and an income to benefit ratio keeps everything in line.  The whole concept is to cover a loss, not to make a profit.  For example, a man makes $50k a year.  His wife takes out a $500k life insurance policy, 10 times his income, and sleeps better at night knowing the her and the children will be able to replace his lost income if he dies.

But investors, strangers with no insurable interest, have also gotten involved with life insurance seeking profits.  Let’s take, for example, an investors finding a 72 year old man in average health, and convince him to take out a $1 million dollar policy on his life by paying him a lump sum to transfer ownership.  Age 72, male, standard non tobacco premiums on a guaranteed UL are currently $38,415 a year.   Best health rates are $28,346 a year, but in the logic of this type of deal, it’s better to find someone less healthy; they don’t live as long.  Investors pay the premiums and collect the $1 million when the insured dies.  This is called stranger owner life insurance or SOLI for short.  The practice has an unsavory history.

By the mid-18th century, purchasing policies on strangers had become a popular form of gambling. Investors often placed their money into “dead pools” insuring the lives of well-known public figures, particularly those with such problems as gout or alcoholism, or those who were likely to be challenged by political enemies and engaged in duels. Such “investors” would often offer targeted insureds lavish dinners and “a drink or two on me”–or would use other means to assure the certainty and accelerate the realization of their investment.

How much of an impact this court ruling will have depends on how broad an interpretation is for the term “stranger-originated”.   Typically, the insured is initially the owner, and then assigns ownership to a stranger a short time after policy issue.   Application now have specific questions about intent of the policy to be assigned, so transfers of ownership will be looked upon closely for more traditional insurable interest.

Reversing ground on stranger owner life insurance is good news.  Speculating on someone’s death is bound to lead to abuses, and speculation on life insurance, where policies are issued regardless of need, runs up the cost for the legitimate consumer.

Turning 70

About to turn 70?  Just turned 70?  70 is a very good milestone to finalize life insurance planning.


Current policy owners

Term policy holders:  Health not what it used to be?  Many term policies allow conversion to permanent to age 70, and the definition of age 70 usually is nearest attained age, meaning up to age 70 1/2.   There is no health evaluation for conversion.  Any agent can help on conversion.   Please contact me for details.

Permanent policy holders:  is it really permanent?  Do not assume your coverage will last a lifetime.  Most permanent policies sold over the last 30 years are universal life (UL), not whole life.  UL’s are tricky depending on their structure and cash value.  A great many will lapse for insufficient cash value.  Conduct a policy review to evaluate how long your policy is projected to last.  Request an in force illustration from your carrier.  It may be a better deal to replace your current coverage by transferring the cash value into a new plan that has lifetime guarantees.   Regardless, keep in mind cash value can be used to offset your premium payments.   This may be an appropriate strategy depending on the amount of cash value, and is often the best way to wind down the policy for those in failing  health.

 

New coverage       Available at most health levels.  You’d be surprised.

The best is called guaranteed universal life.   Premiums and coverage are locked in for life, to age 121,  with a lapse protection guarantee.   Click here for age 70 quotes for $25,000 to $5,000,000 in coverage, or refer the right hand side of my website for quotes.


Final Expenses   (Burial Insurance)   $3,000  to  $25,000

Guaranteed universal life.    There are also small whole life plans.

 

Estate Planning   $25,000 to  $5,000,000

Guaranteed Universal Life.   Companies are very competitive and willing to write coverage for people in their 70’s.

 

Term life insurance is not a good choice.  Term is less expensive because you will probably outlive it.  If  you need term life insurance, to pay off a debt or other obligations, I strongly recommend Genworth’s Term UL, because it automatically converts over to Universal life insurance to age 105 at a fixed rate.

 

Image source:  Wikipedia Commons

Financial planners may be wrong on life insurance

Do you have a life insurance policy purchased in the 1980’s or 90’s? It’s time for an independent review.  Do not necessarily expect the agent or financial planner that sold it to you to give you objective recommendations on its status. I reviewed a policy this week where a financial planner gave years of bad advice and continued to do so, even as the policy projected to go off the cliff. A financial planner may be unqualified, too busy or lack the financial incentive in revamping your life insurance coverage. Here’s what you should recognize if you bought a policy in that era:

  • Do not assume the policy is whole life.   Generally, they are universal life (UL).    There’s a big difference.

Continue reading “Financial planners may be wrong on life insurance”

The need for life insurance

Since September is life insurance awareness month, here a few thoughts on the need for life insurance.

Real life testimonials of life insurance beneficiaries are compelling.  Neil Frankle of the WealthPilgrim.com has a memorable personal story of being orphaned at 17 and unexpectedly receiving $25,000 in life insurance that his father inadvertently signed up for as a loan condition.

Yes, but aren’t the odds of dying before one’s time fairly rare?  Modern life is certainly not as prone to unexpected death as it was 100 years ago with tuberculosis, cholera, typhoid scarlet fever and pneumonia.   There was the flu pandemic of 1918 and another could conceivably happen.  The West Coast could see an earthquake on the order of magnitude as the San Francisco earthquake of 1906.

But in America today, on a day to day basis, the main risk to one’s life is in a car.  It’s routine to travel at speeds above 50 mph, trusting your life to drivers passing by who may be drunk, distracted, unskilled or infirm. Fatalities run around 33,000 a year in the US.   It’s possible to be another one, and entirely not your fault.

If you are raising children, get some life insurance.   Term is cheap.  Don’t let your kids down.

For example, Genworth, preferred non tobacco, 10 year term rates for men, $100,000 in coverage:

age 31 – $8.11 a month
age 36 – $8.37 a month
age 46 – $13.64 a month
age 51 – $19.68 a month

Genworth has $50,000 10 year term that’s even cheaper.   Woman’s rates are even less than for men.

Continue reading “The need for life insurance”

Small permanent life insurance in your 60’s and 70’s

Looking for a smaller life insurance policy for final expenses?   What’s best?   It depends on how much coverage you need.

American General Life recently sent agents and brokers a notice that they were lowering their prices on the whole life product, called American Elite Whole Life.   They had pretty good prices already, so I looked into it.  For example,  a $10,000 whole life policy with American General for a female 68 non tobacco is $48.20 a month.   That beats Liberty Bankers Life $51.97 a month.   Both are “non par” or non participating whole life: no dividends and so the face amount is level; it will always be a $10,000 benefit.  American General has paid up insurance.  That’s a plus if you decide to stop paying premiums.  You would have the option to surrender the policy for its cash value or keep a smaller paid up policy.   For example, after 10 years this 68 year old female would have the option of taking $2,330 in cash value or keeping $3,918 in paid up insurance. American General however requires full underwriting, meaning a blood test and possibly a review of medical records, for people over 55.  Liberty Bankers life is simplified issue, no blood test.

In contrast a $25,000 guaranteed universal life policy with North American is $47.68 a month at their best rate, $50.26 at preferred non tobacco and $64.03 at standard non tobacco.   This required full underwriting: blood test and usually medical records.

$25,000 of coverage for $50.26 a month or $10,000 for $48.20 a month?   Easy choice.  You pay about the same for a $25,000 guaranteed UL as a $10,000 whole life.  Both offer permanent life insurance coverage at a fixed rate.   American General’s whole life only real advantage is if you terminated the policy.  You have the choice of the guaranteed cash surrender value or reduced paid up coverage.  North American guaranteed UL builds little or no cash value, but if you pay on time the coverage is guaranteed to age 120.  Guaranteed Universal Life is a better deal.

What if all you need is something like $5,000 or $8,000 in coverage?   Let’s use female age 68 non smoker again as an example.   For $5,000 it’s $24.10 a month with American General and $28.22 with Liberty Bankers Life.  For $8,000 it’s $38.56 with American General and $42.57 a month with Liberty Bankers Life.   American General is less expensive.  It would depend on your individual health situation, because American General requires more underwriting.   Regardless, look to whole life for coverage amounts less than $10,000.

Face amounts as low as $5,000, $1,000 for term conversions.

8/8/2011, quotes , non tobacco, rates subject to change, quote accuracy or completeness not guaranteed

image source: Wikimedia commons

Term vs. Permanent it’s all a matter of age

Should one choose term or permanent life insurance?   Granted every situation is different, but a general guideline is simple.  Go by the age you need to cover.

Term before retirement and permanent after retirement –  Term to replace a breadwinner’s lost income: permanent for final expenses or estate planning.

Term –   pre-retirement

  • 20’s:  30 year term
  • 30’s:  30 year term
  • 40’s:  20 or 25 year term
  • 50’s:  10 or 15 year term
  • 60’s:  10 year term

7 to 10 times annual salary is general rule of thumb. Most important: get something with affordable premiums.  If need be, drop back on the term length, rather than the face amount, for affordability.

If you have children, get term long enough to cover your youngest child past college age.  For example, if your youngest is 9,  a 15 year term.   9 + 15 =  age 24.    It used to be that age 22 was the benchmark year for college graduation, but since the 5 year plan is more the norm, so you may want stretch it out a bit more.

Permanent  –    post-retirement:  60’s, 70’s, 80’s, 90’s

Ideally, start a separate permanent policy in your 30’s, 40’s or 50’s.  If not, permanent is available into one’s 80’s.  If unhealthy, you can convert your term policy into permanent in your 60’s.

First choice: fully underwritten life insurance, which requires a blood test and medical records.  It’s less expensive, and you get more coverage.  There’s a big industry out there, including AARP, that misleads seniors into needlessly expensive no exam term and permanent. That coverage is only plan B if very unhealthy and for permanent only.  Don’t be fooled into no exam term.

North American currently has the best policy for final expenses, a $25,000 guaranteed universal life.

For estate planning purposes there are guaranteed universal life policies at whatever coverage level that suits your objectives.  The most choices are for coverage at $100,000 or more.  Please refer to my sample quotes by age.

Images: Wikimedia Commons

Two life policies to save money

There’s no rule against getting two life insurance policies at the same time. It may fit your situation and help save money. For example, take someone in their late 50’s wanting to protect their spouse by having $500,000 in coverage. One safe and secure option is to have permanent policy, a guaranteed universal life with a lifetime fixed rate no lapse guarantee .

Continue reading “Two life policies to save money”

Heading off trouble to life insurance policies in estate plans

The 2008 “market shock” may have an unwelcomed delayed effect on variable life insurance policies according to an article recently posted by the Wall Street Journal.  Variable life insurance usually refers to variable universal life or VUL.

One key point is the policy holder may only get 30 or 60 days notice that the policy requires more money. Another interesting point was that estate advisers should consult a good life insurance agent.

Edward F. Koren, chair of private wealth services at Holland & Knight in Tampa, Fla., also recently helped a client deal with a troubled policy. Because the policies are complicated, he says, an estate adviser should turn to a very good insurance agent for help. “You need someone who deals with insurance every day,” says Koren.

That advice goes for financial advisers as well.  They may sell life insurance on the side, but it’s doubtful they keep up with it full time.  Get a second opinion by contacting an independent life insurance agent and broker; it never hurts.

A variable life insurance policy owner, or any universal life policy holder, should request from their carrier a current illustration to see how a policy is performing.  A current illustration is much more clear picture of a life insurance policy than an annual statement.

I don’t recommend variable life insurance. It poses too much downside risk to the client, and puts too many eggs in one basket. Life insurance should be a more conservative element to an overall estate plan. There is guaranteed universal life that guarantees coverage to age 121 at a fixed rate.  Also there are universal life products with strong guarantees that build cash value.  Besides now there is indexed universal life that correlates to market performance but has a floor against market losses and is not directly involved in the stock market.

Image: Wikimedia Commons